Subscribe to our Insights newsletter

Our Insights provide informative, inspiring, surprising, and entertaining insights behind the scenes of finance and economics, as well as society or art. The monthly newsletter keeps you up to date.

 

Investment strategy

How steel - decarbonised - can be part of the solution

Steel will remain essential for the transition to a greener future. So decarbonising the manufacturing process of this key material for many renewable energy technologies is vital for reducing CO2 emissions from supply chains.

Date
Author
Davide Pinna, Senior Equity Analyst, LGT Private Banking
Reading time
5 minutes

A man in protective gear works at a workbench in a factory setting, with welding sparks flying as he works.
Steel has long been part of the emissions problem, but it can also be part of the solution - rapid decarbonisation is key to building a new green economy, says Davide Pinna of LGT Private Banking. © Shutterstock/Gorodenkoff

Achieving net zero greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by mid-century is one of the most important challenges of our time. It's an undertaking of unprecedented scale, involving every major sector of society, and requiring nothing less than a complete transformation of the way we produce, transport, and consume energy and goods.

The rapid deployment of clean energy technologies to improve energy efficiency is at the heart of the net zero transition plans described by the International Energy Agency. Under these plans, increased investment in clean energy will eliminate the need for new conventional energy projects. But some energy suppliers argue that this is not the only way to get to net zero by 2050. More efficient emission reduction technologies, the introduction of sustainable energy sources, and adjustments to the energy consumption mix will also have an impact.

Steel will be indispensable in many areas.

GHG emissions from steel production are still rising

A man in workwear stands outside on a factory site, with wind turbines spinning in the background.
Steel producers are exploring various technologies for decarbonisation, including hydrogen-based direct reduction, carbon capture and storage, and the use of biomass. © Patrick Junker/laif

Today the steel industry is a significant contributor to GHG emissions, particularly carbon dioxide (CO2). Producing iron and steel uses carbon-intensive fuels like coal and natural gas, which create the very high temperatures required to melt the raw materials. Given that steel will continue to be needed to support the green transition, sustainable energy companies are working with steel producers to develop low-carbon steel and thus reduce emissions.

This isn't an easy task. Average global CO2 emission intensities have been rising, largely due to increased steel production in China and India. On average, the CO2 emission intensity of global crude steel production is about 1.8 to 2.0 ton of CO2 per ton of steel produced. To put this in perspective, about 85 average cars driving 100 km each would collectively emit 1 ton of CO2.

Emissions depend on the production technique

However, steel industry emissions are heavily dependent on the technology employed. The blast furnace-basic oxygen furnace (BF-BOF) is the traditional method for heating iron ore to produce steel. This system mainly uses coking coal as an input material, with emissions typically around 2 ton of CO2 per ton of steel.

The electric arc furnace (EAF) uses electricity to melt mainly recycled steel scrap, producing a smaller carbon footprint compared to the BF-BOF system. Emissions are between 0.4 and 0.7 ton of CO2 per ton of steel produced. These outputs can be considerably lower if renewable energy is used.

Fuel determines the production method

More than 70 % of the world's steel is produced using the BF-BOF system, with the other 30 % employing the EAF method. The split varies between regions, with China and India both using BF-BOF for 90 % of their output. Many countries in Asia have ample reserves of iron ore and coal, making this system more economically viable here. In the Middle East, the abundant and relatively cheap natural gas used to generate electricity makes the EAF method more competitive. In Africa, significant hydroelectric power resources also make EAF more attractive.

New decarbonisation technologies are coming

A factory facility nestled in a green, hilly landscape.
ComBio, based in Brazil, provides heavy industry with energy from biomass. The company is supported by Lightrock, the impact investor supported by LGT Private Banking. © ComBio

To help meet the ambitious targets to reduce carbon emission intensity by mid-century, several promising decarbonisation technologies are being developed within the steel industry. These include:

  • Hydrogen-based direct reduction: Iron ore is reduced using hydrogen gas instead of carbon-based fuels to produce direct reduced iron or hot briquetted iron. As hydrogen can be produced from sustainable sources, this process enables a significant reduction in carbon emissions.
  • Carbon capture and storage (CCS): These technologies aim to capture CO2 emissions from steelmaking processes and store them underground. CCS can be applied to both blast furnaces and direct reduction processes. Captured CO2 can be used in the production of chemicals and materials, or for enhanced oil recovery.
  • Biomass and bioenergy: Biomass can be substituted for fossil fuels in BF-BOF systems. Bioenergy with CCS is another variation. Both can help to reduce carbon intensity.

Recycling and the circular economy: Recycling steel scrap using EAF plants requires less energy and emits less CO2 than primary BF-BOF steel production. Optimising production processes, improving heat recovery systems, and integrating advanced control systems to minimise energy waste can all contribute to reduced emissions.

These technologies are at various stages of development, and widespread adoption will require further research, investment, and policy support.

Steel will continue to be critical

A man in a suit and tie poses, smiling at the camera.
Davide Pinna, LGT Private Banking

Steel plays a crucial role in the energy transition. It is used extensively in the construction of renewable energy infrastructure, including wind turbines, solar power systems, and hydropower facilities. Steel is essential for the transmission and distribution of electricity, particularly across long distances, and is a key element in electric vehicle manufacturing and the charging infrastructure. It is also required for CCS and hydrogen capture facilities, including pipelines and storage tanks.

So far steel has only been seen as part of the GHG emissions problem. But it can also be part of the solution. And since many renewable energy projects currently cannot be delivered without steel, it is important to decarbonise steel production as quickly and effectively as possible. This is an important and growing area of the new, green economy.

Factory smokestack with cloud of smoke against the sky
Investment strategy

A counter-intuitive approach to the climate challenge

Often, investors who care about sustainability steer clear of high-carbon-emitting companies. But there can be value in investing in firms willing to transform their businesses to make a contribution to decarbonisation.
A middle-aged man with dark hair stands at a lectern and speaks.
Sustainability

"A gigantic transformation process"

H.S.H. Prince Max von und zu Liechtenstein, Chairman LGT, discusses the pivotal role of education in addressing climate change and shares his vision for the evolution of impact investing in the decades ahead.
Satellite image of a hurricane
Sustainability

Will AI be the key to climate adaptation?

The market for climate adaptation is growing fast, also thanks to AI. But it also faces a number of challenges.
Green fields
Sustainability

Stewardship, or how investors can promote change by becoming more active owners

Investors are increasingly using their influence with investee companies to promote long term sustainable behaviours. We interviewed Emmet McNamee, Head of Progression and Innovation at the UN supported Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) to find out more about the use of stewardship...
Subscribe to Insights